Ucc±r±dicha¹¹anakath±

20. Ucc±r±dicha¹¹anakath±ya½ aµµhame ucc±r±dicha¹¹ane “ucc±r±dibh±vo, anapalokana½,va¼ańjanaµµh±na½, tirokuµµap±k±rat±, cha¹¹ana½ v± cha¹¹±pana½ v±ti im±ni panettha pańca aŖg±ni,navame harit³pari cha¹¹ane sabbesanti bhikkhussa bhikkhuniy± ca. Idha khettap±lak± ±r±m±digopak±ca s±mik± ev±”ti ettakameva s±ratthad²paniya½ (s±rattha. µ². p±cittiya 3.830)vutta½. Vimativinodaniya½ (vi. vi. µ². p±cittiya 2.830) pana “aµµhame va¼ańjiyam±natirokuµµ±dit±,anapaloketv± ucc±r±d²na½ cha¹¹an±d²ti dve aŖg±ni. Navame ‘matthakacchinnan±¼ikeramp²’tivuttatt± harit³pari cha¹¹anameva paµikkhitta½. Ten±ha ‘anikkhittab²jes³’ti-±di.Yattha ca cha¹¹etu½ vaµµati, tattha harite vacc±di½ k±tumpi vaµµati eva. Sabbesanti bhikkhubhikkhun²nan”tivutta½. Vajirabuddhiµ²k±ya½ (vajira. µ². p±cittiya 832) pana “s±mike apaloketv±vacha¹¹et²ti katthaci potthake natthi, katthaci atthi, atthibh±vova seyyo kiriy±kiriyatt±sikkh±padassa. Idha khettap±lak± ±r±m±digopak± ca s±mik± eva. ‘SaŖghassa khette ±r±me ca tattha kacavara½ na cha¹¹etabbanti katik± ce natthi, bhikkhussa cha¹¹etu½ vaµµati saŖghapariy±pannatt±, na bhikkhun²na½. T±sampi bhikkhunisaŖghasantake vuttanayenavaµµati, na tattha bhikkhussa. Eva½ santepi s±ruppavaseneva k±tabbanti vuttan”ti vutta½.
BhikkhuvibhaŖge pana sekhiyavaŗŗan±ya½ (p±ci. aµµha. 651) “asańcicc±ti paµicchannaµµh±na½gacchantassa sahas± ucc±ro v± pass±vo v± nikkhamati, asańciccakato n±ma, an±patti.Na hariteti ettha yampi j²varukkhassa m³la½ pathaviya½ dissam±na½ gacchati, s±kh± v±bh³milagg± gacchati, sabba½ haritasaŖkh±tameva, khandhe nis²ditv± appaharitaµµh±ne p±tetu½vaµµati. Appaharitaµµh±na½ olokentasseva sahas± nikkhamati, gil±naµµh±ne µhito hoti,vaµµati. Appaharite katoti appaharita½ alabhantena tiŗaŗ¹upaka½ v± pal±laŗ¹upaka½v± µhapetv± katopi pacch± harita½ ottharati, vaµµatiyeva. ‘Khe¼ena cettha siŖgh±ŗik±pisaŖgahit±’ti mah±paccariya½ vutta½. Na udaketi eta½ paribhoga-udakameva sandh±ya vutta½.Vaccakuµisama-udd±di-udakesu pana aparibhogesu an±patti. Deve vassante samantatoudakogho hoti, anudakaµµh±na½ olokentasseva nikkhamati, vaµµati. Mah±paccariya½ vutta½et±dise k±le anudakaµµh±na½ alabhantena k±tu½ vaµµat²”ti vutta½. Tassa½ vaŗŗan±ya½vimativinodaniyańca (vi. vi. µ². p±cittiya 2.652) “khe¼ena cettha siŖgh±ŗik±pisaŖgahit±ti ettha udakagaŗ¹usaka½ katv± ucchukacavar±dińca mukheneva haritu½ udakesucha¹¹etu½ vaµµat²ti daµµhabban”ti vutta½.
Imasmi½ µh±ne paŗ¹itehi vic±retabba½ atthi– “vaccakuµisamudd±di-udakesu pana aparibhogesuan±patt²”ti aµµhakath±ya½ vutta½, eva½ sante nad²j±tassar±d²su ±patti v± an±pattiv±ti. Tattha samudd±d²ti ±di-saddena nad²j±tassar±pi saŖgahit±va, tasm± an±patt²tice? Na ceva½ daµµhabba½. Yadi hi samudd±d²ti ettha ±di-saddena nad²j±tassar±pi aŖgahit±, eva½ sati µ²k±cariy± vadeyyu½, na pana vadanti, aµµhakath±yańca “vaccakuµisamudd±di-udakes³”tiettakameva vadeyya, tath± pana avatv± “aparibhoges³”ti hetumantavisesanapadampi gahita½.Tena ń±yati “±disaddena aparibhog±ni candanik±di-udak±ni eva gahit±ni, na paribhog±ninad²j±tassar±di-udak±n²”ti. Tena ca vaccakuµisamudd±di-udak±ni aparibhogatt± an±pattikar±nihonti, nad²j±tassar±di-udak±ni pana paribhogatt± ±pattikar±n²ti. Katha½ pana “aparibhoges³”tiimassa padassa hetumantapadabh±vo j±nitabboti? Yuttito ±gamato ca. Katha½ yuttito?“Vaccakuµisamudd±di-udak±ni paribhog±nipi santi, aparibhog±nip²”ti abyabhic±riyabh±vato.Byabhic±re hi sambhave eva sati visesana½ s±tthaka½ siy±. Katha½ ±gamato? Vuttańheta½±cariyabuddhadattattherena vinayavinicchaye (vi. vi. 1954) “tesa½ aparibhogatt±”ti.Tasm± ±di-saddena aparibhog±niyeva udak±ni gahit±ni, na paribhog±ni. Vuttańheta½vinayavinicchayaµ²k±ya½ “vaccakuµisamudd±di-udakes³ti ettha ±di-saddena sabba½aparibhogajala½ saŖgayhati, teneva tesa½ aparibhogattameva k±raŗam±h±”ti, tasm± manuss±na½paribhogesu nad²j±tassarata¼±kapokkharaŗiy±di-udakesu ucc±rapass±v±dikaraŗa½ na vaµµat²tij±nitabbameta½. “Deve vassante samantato udakogho hoti, anudakaµµh±na½ olokentassevanikkhamati, vaµµati. Mah±paccariya½ vutta½ et±dise k±le anudakaµµh±na½ alabhantenak±tu½ vaµµat²ti vuttan”ti aµµhakath±ya½ ±gatatt± mahantesu nad²j±tassar±d²su ±v±d²hi gatak±le t±dise k±raŗe sati “t²ra½ upaneh²”ti vatv± “upanetu½asakkuŗeyyaµµh±ne udakepi k±tu½ vaµµati, an±patt²”ti aµµhakath±nulomato vińń±yati,upaparikkhitv± gahetabba½.