Ek³nasattatidvisatacatukkakath±vaŗŗan±

59-60. “Mata½ yebhuyyena akkh±yitan”ti vacanato amata½ yebhuyyena kh±yitampi p±r±jikavatthumev±tidasseti. Sabbaso kh±yita½, upp±µita½ v± thullaccayavatthumev±ti dasseti, tath± “yebhuyyenakh±yitan”ti vacanato mata½ sabbakh±yita½, upp±µita½ v± dukkaµavatth³ti dasseti.Na ca s±vasesa½ pańńapenti. Ki½ k±raŗ±? Idańhi sikkh±pada½ lokavajja½,na paŗŗattivajja½. Tattha sikkh±padanti p±r±jika½ adhippeta½. Tattha thullaccayampihi lokavajja½, na paŗŗattivajja½. Atha v± ubhayampi anavasesa½ pańńatta½. P±r±jikakhettehi heµµhimakoµi½ p±petv± µhapite tato para½ thullaccayanti pańńattameva hoti. Tatthathullaccayakhettampi p±r±jikakhetta½ viya heµµhimaparicchedena vuttanti veditabba½. Upa¹¹hakkh±yitethullaccayanti yattha nimitta½ kh±yita½, ta½ dukkaµavatth³ti veditabba½. Etth±ha–paŗŗattivajja½ ki½ s±vasesameva bhagav± pańń±pet²ti? Na. Eka½sato pana yath±sambhava½ tatthatattha pak±sayiss±ma, kimattha½ pana bhagav± upa¹¹hakkh±yite p±r±jika½ na pańń±pes²tiaya½ t±va apucch± buddhavisayatt± vinayapańńattiy±. Ida½ panettha k±raŗapatir³paka½ “upa¹¹habh±vassadubbinicchayatt±”ti. Yebhuyyena kh±yita½ n±ma vaccamaggapass±vamaggamukh±na½ cat³sukoµµh±sesu dve koµµh±se atikkamma y±va tatiyakoµµh±sapariyos±n± kh±dita½, tatiyakoµµh±sa½atikkamma y±va catutthakoµµh±sapariyos±n± dukkaµavatthu.
Yadipi nimitta½ sabbaso kh±yitanti “j²vam±nakasar²ra½yeva sandh±ya vuttan”tivadanti, ta½ v²ma½sitv± gahetabba½. Allasar²reti abhinave, akuthite v±manuss±na½ j²vam±nasar²re akkhin±s±d²su thullaccayameva. Tiracch±nagat±na½ hatthi-ass±d²na½n±s±ya vatthikose ca thullaccayanti “amaggena amagga½ paveseti, ±patti thullaccayass±”tiim±ya p±¼iy± atthavisesenettha vutta½. Upakacchak±d²su dukkaµa½, sabbesampitiracch±nagat±na½ akkhikaŗŗavaŗesu dukkaµa½, avasesasar²repi dukkaµamev±ti ida½vin²tavatthusmi½ “ehi, bhante, methuna½ dhamma½ paµisev±”ti “Ala½ bhaginineta½ kappat²”ti (p±r±. 79) imin± t±va methunar±g±bh±vo dassito hoti. “Ehi,bhante, ³runtarik±ya ghaµµehi…pe… so bhikkhu tath± ak±s²”ti imin± t±vamocanass±do dassito hoti, tenev±ha bhagav± “±patti saŖgh±disesass±”ti. “Yopana methunar±gena ³runtarik±ya ghaµµeti, tassa dukkaµan”ti siddhanti katv± vutta½.
Manuss±na½ akkhikaŗŗavaŗ±di thullaccayavatthu, tiracch±nagat±na½ dukkaµavatth³tiettha duvińńeyyo p±¼ileso, tasm± “na ca, bhikkhave, rattacittena aŖgaj±ta½ chupitabba½,yo chupeyya, ±patti thullaccayass±”ti vacanato rattacittena akkhikaŗŗavaŗa½ chupantassadukkaµanti siddhanti aya½ cammakkhandhake p±¼ilesoti veditabbo. “J²vam±nakapurisass±tij²vam±nakasaddo mate vattabbameva natth²ti ń±panattha½ vutto”ti vadanti. Mah±-aµµhakath±ya½pan±ti ida½ kińc±pi “katv± mah±-aµµhakatha½ sar²ran”ti vutta½, atha kho sesa-aµµhakath±su“methunar±gena mukhen±”ti vacan±bh±vato tattheva bh±vato ta½ vacana½ p±¼ivacanena sa½sanditv±dassanattha½ vutta½. Anugaŗµhipade pana “ta½ sabbamp²ti mah±-aµµhakath±yameva methunar±genaitthiy± nimitta½ appavesento chupati, thullaccayan”ti ca vutta½. “Methunar±genamukhen±”tipi katthaci, p±¼iya½ avisesena “na ca, bhikkhave, rattacittena aŖgaj±ta½chupitabban”ti vutta½, tasm± “ta½ sabban”ti vutta½. Purima½ pasa½sant²titiracch±nagati…pe… vuttanayeneva thullaccaya½, k±yasa½saggar±gena dukkaµanti-±di-aµµhakath±vacanehisa½sandanato. “Ta½ sabbampi…pe… purima½ pasa½sant²”ti ida½ saŖg²titopacch± s²ha¼ad²pakehi ±cariyehi p±¼iy±, aµµhakath±yańca vuttavacana½ sa½sanditv± vuttavinicchayotivutta½. Ettha itarath± h²ti pakatimukhena. Kasm± dukkaµanti ce? “AŖgulib²j±d²nipavesentassa dukkaµan”ti vuttatt± yutta½. Tiracch±nagatitthiy± pass±vamagganti etthamah±-aµµhakath±yampi pubbe “nimittan”ti vatv± ettha “pass±vamaggan”ti vuttatt± avasesanimittedukkaµanti yutta½ viya dissati. Vuttanayenev±ti methunar±gena. Thullaccayantica khandhake pass±vanimittavasenev±gatatt± upaparikkhitv± gahetabba½.

Ek³nasattatidvisatacatukkakath±vaŗŗan± niµµhit±.