Ida½ panettha upp±danirodhesu niyamalakkhaºa½– sakalepi hi imasmi½ khandhayamake tattha tattha uppann±na½ satt±na½ pavatte y±va maraº± v± khandh±na½ apariyantesu upp±danirodhesu vijjam±nesupi lahuparivatt±na½ dhamm±na½ vinibbhoga½ katv± upp±danirodhe dassetu½ na sukaranti pavattiya½ upp±danirodhe an±masitv± paµisandhi-upp±davaseneva upp±dav±ro, nirodhamaraºak±le nirodhavaseneva ca nirodhav±ro kathito. Evamettha upp±danirodhesu niyamalakkhaºa½ viditv± paµisandhi-upp±dameva ca cutinirodhameva ca gahetv± tesu tesu µh±nesu ±gat±na½ pucch±vissajjan±na½ atthavinicchayo veditabbo.
Paµilomanaye pana sabbesa½ cavant±nanti maraºacittassa bhaªgakkhaºasamann±gat±na½. Tesa½ hi tattha r³pakkhandho nuppajjati, vedan±kkhandho ca cuticittassa uppattikkhaºe eva uppannatt±. “Yattha r³pakkhandho nuppajjati, tattha vedan±kkhandho nuppajjat²”ti pucch±ya ar³pabhava½ sandh±ya “uppajjat²”ti ida½ vissajjana½ kata½, anantarapucch±ya asaññibhava½ sandh±ya “uppajjat²”ti ida½ vissajjananti veditabba½. Sesa½ suviññeyyamev±ti aya½ paccuppannak±le nayo.
Yath± ca paccuppannak±le saµµhi yamak±d²ni, eva½ sesesupi pañcasu k±labhedesu paccekanti gahetabba½. Pucch±vissajjanesu panettha kiñc±pi “yassa r³pakkhandho uppajjittha, tassa vedan±kkhandho uppajjitth±ti? ¾mant±”ti-±din±, “yattha r³pakkhandho uppajjittha, tattha vedan±kkhandho uppajjitth±ti? Pañcavok±re uppajjittha, n±ññatth±”ti-±din± ca, “yassa yattha r³pakkhandho uppajjittha, tassa tattha vedan±kkhandho uppajjitth±ti? Pañcavok±r±na½ tesa½ tattha uppajjittha, n±ññatth±”ti-±din± ca at²tak±le anulomanaye, “yassa r³pakkhandho nuppajjittha, tassa vedan±kkhandho nuppajjitth±ti? Natth²”ti-±din±, “yattha r³pakkhandho nuppajjittha, tattha vedan±kkhandho nuppajjitth±ti? Uppajjitth±”ti-±din±, “yassa yattha r³pakkhandho nuppajjittha, tassa tattha vedan±kkhandho nuppajjitth±ti? Ar³p±na½ tesa½ tattha r³pakkhandho nuppajjittha, no ca tesa½…pe… suddh±v±s±na½ tesa½ tattha tadubhaya½ nuppajjitth±”ti-±din± t²su v±resu paµilomanaye ca,
“Yassa r³pakkhandho uppajjissati, tassa vedan±kkhandho uppajjissat²ti? ¾mant±”ti-±din±, “yattha r³pakkhandho uppajjissati, tattha vedan±kkhandho uppajjissat²ti…pe… pañcavok±re uppajjissat²”ti-±din±, “yassa yattha r³pakkhandho uppajjissati, tassa tattha vedan±kkhandho uppajjissati…pe… pañcavok±r±na½ tesa½ tattha uppajjissat²”ti-±din± ca an±gatak±le anulomanaye, “yassa r³pakkhandho nuppajjissati, tassa vedan±kkhandho nuppajjissat²ti? Ye ar³pa½ upapajjitv± parinibb±yissanti, tesa½ r³pakkhandho nuppajjissati, netaro, pacchimabhavik±na½ tadubhaya½ nuppajjissat²”ti-±din±, “yattha r³pakkhandho nuppajjissati, tattha vedan±kkhandho nuppajjissat²”ti-±din±, “yassa yattha r³pakkhandho nuppajjissati, tassa tattha vedan±kkhandho nuppajjissat²ti? Ar³p±na½ tesa½ tattha r³pakkhandho nuppajjissati, netaro, pacchimabhavik±na½ tadubhaya½ nuppajjissat²”ti-±din± paµilomanaye ca,
“Yassa r³pakkhandho uppajjati, tassa vedan±kkhandho uppajjitth±”ti-±din±, “yattha r³pakkhandho uppajjati, tattha vedan±kkhandho uppajjitth±ti…pe… pañcavok±re uppajjat²”ti-±din±, “yassa yattha r³pakkhandho uppajjati, tassa tattha vedan±kkhandho uppajjitth±ti? Suddh±v±sa½ asaññasatta½ upapajjant±na½ tesa½ tattha r³pakkhandho uppajjati, no ca tesa½ tattha vedan±kkhandho uppajjittha, pañcavok±re pana uppajjitth±”ti-±din± paccuppannena at²tak±le anulomanaye, “yassa r³pakkhandho nuppajjati, tassa vedan±kkhandho nuppajjitth±”ti-±din±, “yattha r³pakkhandho nuppajjati, tattha vedan±kkhandho nuppajjitth±ti? Uppajjitth±”ti-±din±, “yassa yattha r³pakkhandho nuppajjati tassa tattha vedan±kkhandho nuppajjitth±ti? Pañcavok±r± cavant±na½ ar³p±nañca tesa½ tattha r³pakkhandho nuppajjati, no ca tesa½ tattha vedan±kkhandho nuppajjittha, suddh±v±se parinibbant±na½ asaññasatt± cavant±na½ tesa½ tattha r³pakkhandho ca nuppajjati vedan±kkhandho ca nuppajjitth±”ti-±din± paµilomanaye ca,
“Yassa r³pakkhandho uppajjati, tassa vedan±kkhandho uppajjissat²ti? Pacchimabhavik±na½ pañcavok±ra½ upapajjant±na½ tesa½ r³pakkhandho uppajjat²”ti-±din±, “yattha r³pakkhandho uppajjati, tattha vedan±kkhandho uppajjissat²ti? Pañcavok±re…pe… uppajjissat²”ti-±din± ca, “yassa yattha r³pakkhandho uppajjati, tassa tattha vedan±kkhandho uppajjissat²ti Pacchimabhavik±na½ pañcavok±re…pe… uppajjissat²”ti-±din± ca paccuppannena an±gatak±le anulomanaye, “yassa r³pakkhandho nuppajjati, tassa vedan±kkhandho nuppajjissat²ti pañcavok±re parinibbant±na½ ar³pe pacchimabhavik±na½…pe… nuppajjissat²”ti-±din±, “yattha r³pakkhandho nuppajjati, tattha vedan±kkhandho nuppajjissat²ti? Uppajjissat²”ti-±din±, “yassa yattha r³pakkhandho nuppajjati, tassa tattha vedan±kkhandho nuppajjissat²ti…pe… pañcavok±re parinibbant±na½ ar³pe pacchimabhavik±na½ asaññasatt± cavant±na½ tesa½ tattha…pe… nuppajjissat²”ti-±din± paµilomanaye ca,
“Yassa r³pakkhandho uppajjittha, tassa vedan±kkhandho uppajjissat²ti? Pacchimabhavik±na½ uppajjissat²”ti-±din±, “yattha r³pakkhandho uppajjittha, tattha vedan±kkhandho uppajjissat²ti…pe… pañcavok±re uppajjissat²”ti-±din±, “yassa yattha r³pakkhandho uppajjittha, tassa tattha vedan±kkhandho uppajjissat²ti? Pañcavok±re pacchimabhavik±na½ asaññasatt±na½…pe… uppajjissat²”ti-±din± at²tena an±gatak±le anulomanaye, “yassa r³pakkhandho uppajjittha, tassa vedan±kkhandho uppajjissat²ti? Natth²”ti-±din±, “yattha r³pakkhandho nuppajjittha, tattha vedan±kkhandho nuppajjissat²ti? Uppajjissat²”ti-±din±, “yassa yattha r³pakkhandho nuppajjittha, tassa tattha vedan±kkhandho nuppajjissat²ti…pe… suddh±v±s±na½ ar³pe pacchimabhavik±na½ tesa½ tattha r³pakkhandho ca nuppajjittha vedan±kkhandho ca nuppajjissat²”ti-±din± paµilomanaye ca suddh± atthavises± upalabbhanti. Tath±pi ganthavitth±rabhayena anavasesato na dassayiss±ma, dassitanayeneva sabbattha pucch±vissajjana½ sakk± paº¹itena ñ±tunti aya½ upp±dav±re nayo.
Yath± ca upp±dav±re chasu k±labhedesu pacceka½ puggal±dibhedato anulomapaµilomanayubhayena cha cha v±r±, ekekasmi½ v±re dasa dasa katv± saµµhi saµµhi yamak±ni, sabb±nipi saµµhi-adhik±ni t²ºi yamakasat±ni, tato dviguº± pucch±, dviguº± atth± ca honti, eva½ nirodhav±re upp±danirodhav±repi veditabb±. Tattha ca “yassa r³pakkhandho nirujjhati, tassa vedan±kkhandho nirujjhat²ti…pe… pañcavok±r± cavant±na½…pe… nirujjhat²”ti-±din±, “yassa r³pakkhandho na nirujjhati, tassa vedan±kkhandho na nirujjhat²ti…pe… sabbesa½ upapajjant±na½…pe… na nirujjhat²”ti-±din± nirodhav±re, “yassa r³pakkhandho uppajjati, tassa vedan±kkhandho nirujjhat²ti? No. Yassa r³pakkhandho nuppajjati, tassa vedan±kkhandho na nirujjhat²ti…pe… ar³pa½ upapajjant±na½ asaññasatt± cavant±na½ tesa½ r³pakkhandho ca nuppajjati, vedan±kkhandho ca na nirujjhat²”ti-±din± upp±danirodhav±re ca heµµh± vutt±nus±rena sabbattha pucch±vissajjananayo ñ±tabboti aya½ pavattiv±re nayo.
Pariññ±v±re pana puggalav±r±d²su t²su puggalav±ro ekova labbhati, na ok±sapuggalok±sav±r± sadisavissajjanatt±. Yo hi koci puggalo r³p±di½ parij±nantova yattha katthaci niruddhopi t±disova hoti, tasm± chasu k±labhedesu anulomato puggalavasena dve dve v±r±, ekekasmi½ v±re dasa dasa katv± v²sati v²sati yamak±n²ti v²sa½ yamakasata½, taddiguº± pucch±, taddiguº± ca atth± veditabb±. Tattha ca “yo r³pakkhandha½ parij±n±ti, so vedan±kkhandha½ parij±n±t²ti? ¾mant±”ti-±din± ca, “yo r³pakkhandha½ na parij±n±ti, so vedan±kkhandha½ na parij±n±t²ti? ¾mant±”ti ±din± ca anulomapaµilomato ±dito t²su k±lesu sabbapucch±na½ “±mant± ±mant±”tveva vissajjana½. Itaresu pana t²su missakak±lesu “yo r³pakkhandha½ parij±n±ti, so vedan±kkhandha½ parij±nitth±ti? No. Yo v± pana…pe… no”ti eva½ itarak±ladvayepi anulomanaye “no no”tveva vissajjana½.
Paµilomanaye pana “yo r³pakkhandha½ na parij±n±ti, so vedan±kkhandha½ na parij±nitth±ti? Arah± r³pakkhandha½ na parij±n±ti, no ca so vedan±kkhandha½ na parij±nittha. Aggamaggasamaªgiñca arahantañca µhapetv± avases± puggal± r³pakkhandhañca na parij±nanti, vedan±kkhandhañca na parij±ni½s³”ti-±din±, “yo r³pakkhandha½ na parij±n±ti, so vedan±kkhandha½ na parij±nissat²ti? Ye magga½ paµilabhissanti, te r³pakkhandha½ na parij±nanti, no ca vedan±kkhandha½ na parij±nissanti. Arah± ye ca puthujjan± magga½ na paµilabhissanti, te r³pakkhandhañca na parij±nanti, vedan±kkhandhañca na parij±nissant²”ti-±din± ca, “yo r³pakkhandha½ na parij±nittha, so vedan±kkhandha½ na parij±nissant²ti? Ye magga½ paµilabhissanti, te r³pakkhandha½ na parij±ni½su, no ca vedan±kkhandha½ na parij±nissanti. Aggamaggasamaªg² ye ca puthujjan± magga½ na paµilabhissanti, te r³pakkhandhañca na parij±ni½su, vedan±kkhandhañca na parij±nissant²”ti-±din± ca pucch±vissajjananayo veditabbo.
Ettha ca at²t±n±gatapaccuppannasaªkh±t± tayo addh± pavattiv±re cutipaµisandhivasena na labbhanti, pavatte cittakkhaºavaseneva labbhanti. Lokuttaramaggakkhaºasmi½ hi nibb±n±rammaºena cittena pañcasu khandhesu pariññ±kiccanipphattiy± ya½ kañci eka½ khandha½ parij±nanto itarampi “parij±n±t²”ti anulomapañhesu pariññ±kiccassa matthakappatta½ aggamaggasamaªgi½ sandh±ya “±mant±”ti vissajjana½ vutta½. “Na parij±n±t²”ti paµilomapañhesu puthujjan±dayo sandh±ya “±mant±”ti vissajjana½ vuttanti veditabba½. “Parij±nitth±”ti imasmi½ pana at²tak±lav±re magg±nantare aggaphale µhitopi pariññ±kiccassa niµµhitatt± parij±nitthayeva n±ma. “Parij±n±t²”ti ca aggamaggasamaªg² vuccati, “parij±nissant²”ti puthujjan±dayo, tasm± yo na parij±n±ti, so parij±nitth±ti v±, parij±nissat²ti-±din± v± vattu½ asakkuºeyyat±ya “±mant±”ti vissajjana½ kata½.
Paµilomanaye pana “aggamaggasamaªgiñca arahantañca µhapetv±”ti ida½ aggamaggasamaªgino “na parij±n±t²”ti vacana½, arahato ca “na parij±nitth±”ti vattu½ asakkuºeyyat±ya vutta½, “ye ca puthujjan± magga½ na paµilabhissant²”ti imin± at²te viya an±gatepi anantak±la½ amuccanak± satt± n±ma atth²ti dasseti, te ca arahat± niµµhitapariññ±kiccena, “na parij±nissant²”ti vattabbata½ v± ±pannena samak± j±t±, sabbattha ca eka½ khandha½ parij±nanto sabba½ parij±n±ti, aparij±nantopi ca sabba½ na parij±n±t²ti veditabbanti aya½ khandhayamakam±tikatthasa½vaººan±nayo.