5. Pañcamanayo asaªgahitena-asaªgahitapadavaººan±

193. Vuttanayen±ti yasm± saªgahappavattivisesavirahito asaªgahitadhammavisesanissito pañcamanayo, tasm± yo ettha kenaci asaªgahitena dhammavisesena puna asaªgahito dhammaviseso asaªgahitena asaªgahito asaªgahitat±ya pucchitabbo vissajjitabbo ca. Tameva t±va yath±niddh±rita½ dassento “r³pakkhandhena ye dhamm± khandha…pe… asaªgahit±, tehi dhammehi ye dhamm± khandha…pe… asaªgahit±ti ±h±”ti catutthanaye vuttanay±nus±rena. Yath±niddh±ritadhammadassananti p±¼iya½ niddh±ritappak±radhammadassana½. Saha sukhumar³pen±ti sasukhumar³pa½, tena sukhumar³pena saddhi½ gahita½ viññ±ºa½, tena sahitadhammasamud±y± sasukhuma…pe… d±y±. Ke pana teti ±ha “dukkhasacc±”ti-±di. Kesañc²ti nibb±nacakkh±yatan±d²na½. T²hipi saªgahehi. Paripuººasaªgahehi t²hipi saªgahehi asaªg±hak± paripuººasaªgah±saªg±hak±. Aby±katadhammasadis± nevadassanenanabh±van±yapah±tabbanevasekkh±n±sekkh±dayo. Itareti r³pakkhandh±dayo. Tabbipariy±yen±ti vuttavipariy±yena, t²hipi saªgahehi asaªgahetabbassa atthit±ya paripuººasaªgah±saªg±hakatt±ti attho.
Asaªg±hakesu nibb±na½ antogadha½, tasm± ta½ anidassana-appaµighehi asaªgahetabba½ na hot²ti attho. Ten±ha “na ca tadeva tassa asaªg±hakan”ti. “Vedan±kkhandhena ye dhamm±”ti-±dayo nava pañh± dutiyapañh±dayo, te paµhamapañhena saddhi½ dasa, n±mar³papañh±dayo pana catuv²sat²ti ±ha “sabbepi catutti½sa hont²”ti. R³pakkhandh±divisesakapadanti “r³pakkhandhen±”ti-±din± asaªg±hakattena visesaka½ r³pakkhandh±dipada½. Pucch±y±ti ca pucchanatthanti attho. “R³pakkhandhen±”ti-±di sabbampi v± viññ±petu½ icchitabh±vena vacana½ pañhabh±vato pucch±. Ten±ha aµµhakath±ya½ “pañh± panettha…pe… catutti½sa hont²”ti. Te hi lakkhaºato dassit±ti te niddh±ritadhamm± teneva asaªgahit±saªgahitat±ya niddh±raºasaªkh±tena lakkhaºena dassit±.
Tadev±ti eva-sadden±ti “tadev±”ti ettha eva-saddena. “Ya½ pucch±ya uddhaµa½ pada½, ta½ khandh±d²hi asaªgahitan”ti ettha “khandh±d²hev±”ti avadh±raºa½ nippayojana½ pak±rantarassa abh±vato. “T²hi asaªgaho”ti hi vutta½. Tath± “asaªgahitamev±”ti saªgahitat±nivattanassa anadhippetatt±. Tadev±ti pana icchita½ uddhaµasseva asaªgahitena-asaªgahitabh±vassa avadh±retabbatt±ti dassento “na kad±c²”ti-±dim±ha. Tattha aññass±ti anuddhaµassa. Aniyatata½ dasset²ti ida½ avadh±raºaphaladassana½. Niyamatoti sakk± vacanaseso yojetunti idampi eva-k±rena siddhamevattha½ p±kaµatara½ k±tu½ vutta½. Yato hi eva-k±ro, tato aññattha niyamoti. Eva½pak±ramev±ti pucch±ya uddhaµappak±rameva, ya½ pak±ra½ pucch±ya uddhaµa½, ta½pak±ramev±ti attho. Tass±ti asaªgahitassa. Aññass±ti pucch±ya anuddhaµappak±rassa. Etena yo pucch±ya uddhaµo t²hipi saªgahehi asaªgahito, tasseva idha pucchitabbavissajjitabbabh±vo, na aññass±ti dasseti. Ten±ha “pucch±ya uddhaµañh²”ti-±di. ¾yatanadh±tusaªgahavasena cettha r³pakkhandh±d²na½ aññasahitat±, viññ±ºakkhandh±d²na½ asahitat± ca veditabb±.
Avases± vedan±dayo tayo khandh± nibb±nañca sakalena r³pakkhandhena tesa½ saªgaho natth²ti “saªgahit±”ti na sakk± vattu½, ekadesena pana saªgaho atth²ti “asaªgahit± na hont²ti eva½ daµµhabban”ti ±ha. “R³padhamm±v±”ti niyamana½ pucch±ya uddhaµabh±v±pekkhanti dassento “pucch±ya…pe… adhipp±yo”ti ±ha. Tena vutta½ “anuddhaµ± vedan±dayopi hi asaªgahit± ev±”ti. Etth±ti etasmi½ pañcamanayaniddese. Paµhame nayeti paµhame atthavikappe. Tath± dutiyeti etth±pi. R³paviññ±ºeh²ti asukhumar³padhammehi viññ±ºena c±ti ayamettha adhipp±yoti dassento “o¼±rika…pe… attho”ti ±ha. Katha½ pana r³padhamm±ti vutte o¼±rikar³passeva gahaºanti ±ha “r³pekadeso hi ettha r³paggahaºena gahito”ti.
196. Asaªg±hakanti “cakkh±yatanena…pe… asaªgahit±”ti eva½ asaªg±hakabh±vena vutta½ pucchitabbavissajjetabbabh±vena vuttampi k±ma½ vedan±d²heva cat³hi asaªgahita½, ta½ pana na cakkh±yatanamev±ti dassetu½ “cakkh±yatanena pan±”ti-±di vutta½. Yehi dhammeh²ti khandh±d²su yehi. Sabba½ dhammaj±ta½ teva r³p±dike dhamme ud±neti p±¼iya½. Kasm± paneta½ ud±net²ti ±ha “sadisavissajjan±”ti-±di. Paµhamena ud±nena. Dveti “b±hir± up±d± dve”ti ettha vutta½ dve-sadda½ sandh±y±ha. Tassa asaªgahitassa. Yath±dassitass±ti “r³pan”ti-±din± dassitappak±rassa. Dhammanvayañ±ºupp±dana½ nayad±na½. “R³pa½ dhamm±yatanan”ti-±d²na½ pad±na½ vasena dvev²sapadiko esa nayo.

Pañcamanaya-asaªgahitena-asaªgahitapadavaººan± niµµhit±.