2. Dutiyavaggo

(12) 3. Kaªkh±kath±

318. Atthi arahato kaªkh±ti? ¾mant±. Atthi arahato vicikicch± vicikicch±pariyuµµh±na½ vicikicch±sa½yojana½ vicikicch±n²varaºanti? Na heva½ vattabbe…pe….
Natthi arahato vicikicch± vicikicch±pariyuµµh±na½ vicikicch±sa½yojana½ vicikicch±n²varaºanti? ¾mant±. Hañci natthi arahato vicikicch± vicikicch±pariyuµµh±na½ vicikicch±sa½yojana½ vicikicch±n²varaºa½, no ca vata re vattabbe– “atthi arahato kaªkh±”ti.
Atthi puthujjanassa kaªkh±, atthi tassa vicikicch± vicikicch±pariyuµµh±na½ vicikicch±sa½yojana½ vicikicch±n²varaºanti? ¾mant±. Atthi arahato kaªkh±, atthi tassa vicikicch± vicikicch±pariyuµµh±na½ vicikicch±sa½yojana½ vicikicch±n²varaºanti? Na heva½ vattabbe…pe….
Atthi arahato kaªkh±, natthi tassa vicikicch± vicikicch±pariyuµµh±na½ vicikicch±sa½yojana½ vicikicch±n²varaºanti? ¾mant± Atthi puthujjanassa kaªkh±, natthi tassa vicikicch± vicikicch±pariyuµµh±na½ vicikicch±sa½yojana½ vicikicch±n²varaºanti? Na heva½ vattabbe…pe….
Atthi arahato kaªkh±ti? ¾mant±. Atthi arahato satthari kaªkh±, dhamme kaªkh±, saªghe kaªkh±, sikkh±ya kaªkh±, pubbante kaªkh±, aparante kaªkh±, pubbant±parante kaªkh±, idappaccayat±paµiccasamuppannesu dhammesu kaªkh±ti? Na heva½ vattabbe.
Natthi arahato satthari kaªkh±, dhamme kaªkh±…pe… idappaccayat±paµiccasamuppannesu dhammesu kaªkh±ti ¾mant±. Hañci natthi arahato satthari kaªkh±, dhamme kaªkh±…pe… idappaccayat±paµiccasamuppannesu dhammesu kaªkh±, no ca vata re vattabbe– “atthi arahato kaªkh±”ti.
Atthi puthujjanassa kaªkh±, atthi tassa satthari kaªkh±, dhamme kaªkh±…pe… idappaccayat±paµiccasamuppannesu dhammesu kaªkh±ti? ¾mant±. Atthi arahato kaªkh±, atthi tassa satthari kaªkh±, dhamme kaªkh±…pe… idappaccayat±paµiccasamuppannesu dhammesu kaªkh±ti? Na heva½ vattabbe.
Atthi arahato kaªkh±, natthi tassa satthari kaªkh±, dhamme kaªkh±…pe… idappaccayat±paµiccasamuppannesu dhammesu kaªkh±ti? ¾mant±. Atthi puthujjanassa kaªkh±, natthi tassa satthari kaªkh±, dhamme kaªkh±…pe… idappaccayat±paµiccasamuppannesu dhammesu kaªkh±ti? Na heva½ vattabbe.
319. Atthi arahato kaªkh±ti? ¾mant± Nanu arahato r±go pah²no ucchinnam³lo t±l±vatthukato anabh±vaªkato ±yati½ anupp±dadhammoti? ¾mant±. Hañci arahato r±go pah²no ucchinnam³lo t±l±vatthukato anabh±vaªkato ±yati½ anupp±dadhammo, no ca vata re vattabbe– “atthi arahato kaªkh±”ti.
Atthi arahato kaªkh±ti? ¾mant±. Nanu arahato doso pah²no…pe… moho pah²no…pe… anottappa½ pah²na½…pe… r±gappah±n±ya maggo bh±vito…pe… bojjhaªg± bh±vit±…pe… dosappah±n±ya…pe… anottappapah±n±ya maggo bh±vito…pe… bojjhaªg± bh±vit±; nanu arah± v²tar±go v²tadoso v²tamoho…pe… sacchik±tabba½ sacchikatanti? ¾mant±. Hañci arah± v²tar±go v²tadoso v²tamoho…pe… sacchik±tabba½ sacchikata½, no ca vata re vattabbe– “atthi arahato kaªkh±”ti.
320. Atthi arahato kaªkh±ti? Sadhammakusalassa arahato atthi kaªkh±, paradhammakusalassa arahato natthi kaªkh±ti. Sadhammakusalassa arahato atthi kaªkh±ti? ¾mant±. Paradhammakusalassa arahato atthi kaªkh±ti? Na heva½ vattabbe…pe….
Paradhammakusalassa arahato natthi kaªkh±ti? ¾mant±. Sadhammakusalassa arahato natthi kaªkh±ti? Na heva½ vattabbe…pe….
Sadhammakusalassa arahato r±go pah²no, atthi tassa kaªkh±ti? ¾mant±. Paradhammakusalassa arahato r±go pah²no, atthi tassa kaªkh±ti? Na heva½ vattabbe…pe….
Sadhammakusalassa arahato doso pah²no…pe… moho pah²no…pe… anottappa½ pah²na½…pe… r±gappah±n±ya maggo bh±vito…pe… bojjhaªg± bh±vit±…pe… dosappah±n±ya…pe… mohappah±n±ya…pe… anottappapah±n±ya maggo bh±vito…pe… bojjhaªg± bh±vit±…pe… sadhammakusalo arah± v²tar±go v²tadoso v²tamoho pe… sacchik±tabba½ sacchikata½, atthi tassa kaªkh±ti? ¾mant±. Paradhammakusalo arah± v²tar±go v²tadoso v²tamoho…pe… sacchik±tabba½ sacchikata½, atthi tassa kaªkh±ti? Na heva½ vattabbe…pe… paradhammakusalassa arahato r±go pah²no, natthi tassa kaªkh±ti? ¾mant±. Sadhammakusalassa arahato r±go pah²no, natthi tassa kaªkh±ti? Na heva½ vattabbe…pe….
Paradhammakusalassa arahato doso pah²no…pe… moho pah²no…pe… anottappa½ pah²na½…pe… r±gappah±n±ya maggo bh±vito…pe… bojjhaªg± bh±vit±…pe… dosappah±n±ya…pe… mohappah±n±ya…pe… anottappapah±n±ya maggo bh±vito…pe… bojjhaªg± bh±vit±…pe… paradhammakusalo arah± v²tar±go v²tadoso v²tamoho…pe… sacchik±tabba½ sacchikata½, natthi tassa kaªkh±ti? ¾mant±. Sadhammakusalo arah± v²tar±go v²tadoso v²tamoho…pe… sacchik±tabba½ sacchikata½, natthi tassa kaªkh±ti? Na heva½ vattabbe…pe….
321. Atthi arahato kaªkh±ti? ¾mant±. Nanu vutta½ bhagavat±– “j±natoha½, bhikkhave, passato ±sav±na½ khaya½ vad±mi, no aj±nato no apassato! Kiñca, bhikkhave j±nato ki½ passato ±sav±na½ khayo hoti ‘Iti r³pa½’…pe… ‘iti viññ±ºassa atthaªgamo’ti– eva½ kho, bhikkhave, j±nato eva½ passato ±sav±na½ khayo hot²”ti. Attheva suttantoti? ¾mant±. Tena hi na vattabba½– “atthi arahato kaªkh±”ti.
Atthi arahato kaªkh±ti? ¾mant±. Nanu vutta½ bhagavat±– “j±natoha½, bhikkhave, passato ±sav±na½ khaya½ vad±mi, no aj±nato no apassato! Kiñca, bhikkhave, j±nato ki½ passato ±sav±na½ khayo hoti? ‘Ida½ dukkhan’ti, bhikkhave…pe… ‘aya½ dukkhanirodhag±min² paµipad±’ti j±nato passato ±sav±na½ khayo hoti. Eva½ kho bhikkhave, j±nato eva½ passato ±sav±na½ khayo hot²”ti. Attheva suttantoti? ¾mant±. Tena hi na vattabba½– “atthi arahato kaªkh±”ti.
Atthi arahato kaªkh±ti? ¾mant±. Nanu vutta½ bhagavat±– “sabba½, bhikkhave, anabhij±na½ aparij±na½ avir±jaya½ appajaha½ abhabbo dukkhakkhay±ya; sabbañca kho, bhikkhave, abhij±na½ parij±na½ vir±jaya½ pajaha½ bhabbo dukkhakkhay±y±”ti! Attheva suttantoti? ¾mant±. Tena hi na vattabba½– “atthi arahato kaªkh±”ti.
Atthi arahato kaªkh±ti? ¾mant±. Nanu vutta½ bhagavat±– “sah±vassa dassanasampad±ya pe… chacc±bhiµh±n±ni abhabba k±tun”ti. Attheva suttantoti? ¾mant±. Tena hi na vattabba½– “atthi arahato kaªkh±”ti.
Atthi arahato kaªkh±ti? ¾mant±. Nanu vutta½ bhagavat±– “yasmi½, bhikkhave, samaye ariyas±vakassa viraja½ v²tamala½ dhammacakkhu½ udap±di ‘ya½ kiñci samudayadhamma½ sabba½ ta½ nirodhadhamman’ti, saha dassanupp±d±, bhikkhave, ariyas±vakassa t²ºi sa½yojan±ni pah²yanti– sakk±yadiµµhi, vicikicch±, s²labbatapar±m±so”ti! Attheva suttantoti? ¾mant±. Tena hi na vattabba½– “atthi arahato kaªkh±”ti.
Atthi arahato kaªkh±ti? ¾mant±. Nanu vutta½ bhagavat±–
“Yad± have p±tubhavanti dhamm±,
±t±pino jh±yato br±hmaºassa;
athassa kaªkh± vapayanti sabb±,
yato paj±n±ti sahetudhammanti.
“Yad± have p±tubhavanti dhamm±,
±t±pino jh±yato br±hmaºassa;
athassa kaªkh± vapayanti sabb±,
yato khaya½ paccay±na½ aved²ti.
“Yad± have p±tubhavanti dhamm±,
±t±pino jh±yato br±hmaºassa;
vidh³paya½ tiµµhati m±rasena½,
s³riyova [suriyova (s². sy±. ka½. p².)] obh±sayamantalikkhanti [mah±va. 3; ud±. 3].
“Y± k±ci kaªkh± idha v± hura½ v±,
sakavediy± v± paravediy± v±;
jh±yino [ye jh±yino (ud±ne)] t± pajahanti sabb±,
±t±pino brahmacariya½ carant±ti [ud±. 47 ud±nepi].
“Ye kaªkh±samatikkant±, kaªkh±bh³tesu p±ºisu;
asa½say± visa½yutt±, tesu dinna½ mahapphalanti.
“Et±dis² dhammapak±sanettha,
na tattha ki½ kaªkhati koci s±vako;
nitthiººa-ogha½ [nitiººa-ogha½ (s². ka.), nittiººa-ogha½ (sy±. ka½.)] vicikicchachinna½,
buddha½ namass±ma jina½ janind±”ti [d². ni. 2.354].
Attheva suttantoti? ¾mant±. Tena hi na vattabba½– “atthi arahato kaªkh±”ti.
Na vattabba½– “atthi arahato kaªkh±”ti? ¾mant±. Nanu arah± itthipuris±na½ n±magotte kaªkheyya, magg±magge kaªkheyya, tiºakaµµhavanappat²na½ n±me kaªkheyy±”ti? ¾mant±. Hañci arah± itthipuris±na½ n±magotte kaªkheyya, magg±magge kaªkheyya, tiºakaµµhavanappat²na½ n±me kaªkheyya; tena vata re vattabbe– “atthi arahato kaªkh±”ti.
Arah± itthipuris±na½ n±magotte kaªkheyya, magg±magge kaªkheyya, tiºakaµµhavanappat²na½ n±me kaªkheyy±ti, atthi arahato kaªkh±ti? ¾mant±. Arah± sot±pattiphale v± sakad±g±miphale v± an±g±miphale v± arahatte v± kaªkheyy±ti? Na heva½ vattabbe…pe….

Kaªkh±kath± niµµhit±.