21. Saccikaµµhasabh±g±nuyogo

208. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikaµµhaparamatthen±ti? ¾mant±. Puggalo saªkhatoti? Na heva½ vattabbe…pe… puggalo asaªkhatoti? Na heva½ vattabbe…pe… puggalo neva saªkhato n±saªkhatoti? Na heva½ vattabbe.
209. Puggalo neva saªkhato n±saªkhatoti? ¾mant± Saªkhatañca asaªkhatañca µhapetv± atthaññ± tatiy± koµ²ti? Na heva½ vattabbe…pe….
210. Saªkhatañca asaªkhatañca µhapetv± atthaññ± tatiy± koµ²ti? ¾mant±. Nanu vutta½ bhagavat±– “dvem±, bhikkhave, dh±tuyo. Katam± dve? Saªkhat± ca dh±tu asaªkhat± ca dh±tu. Im± kho, bhikkhave, dve dh±tuyo”ti [ma. ni. 1.125, ±lapanamattameva n±na½]! Attheva suttantoti? ¾mant±. Tena hi na vattabba½– “saªkhatañca asaªkhatañca µhapetv± atthaññ± tatiy± koµ²”ti.
211. Puggalo neva saªkhato n±saªkhatoti? ¾mant±. Añña½ saªkhata½, añña½ asaªkhata½, añño puggaloti? Na heva½ vattabbe…pe….
212. Khandh± saªkhat±, nibb±na½ asaªkhata½, puggalo neva saªkhato n±saªkhatoti? ¾mant±. Aññe khandh±, añña½ nibb±na½, añño puggaloti? Na heva½ vattabbe…pe….
213. R³pa½ saªkhata½, nibb±na½ asaªkhata½, puggalo neva saªkhato n±saªkhatoti? ¾mant±. Añña½ r³pa½, añña½ nibb±na½, añño puggaloti? Na heva½ vattabbe. Vedan±… saññ±… saªkh±r±… viññ±ºa½ saªkhata½, nibb±na½ asaªkhata½, puggalo neva saªkhato n±saªkhatoti? ¾mant±. Añña½ viññ±ºa½, añña½ nibb±na½, añño puggaloti? Na heva½ vattabbe…pe….
214. Puggalassa upp±do paññ±yati, vayo paññ±yati, µhitassa aññathatta½ paññ±yat²ti? ¾mant±. Puggalo saªkhatoti? Na heva½ vattabbe…pe… vutta½ bhagavat±– “t²ºim±ni, bhikkhave, saªkhatassa saªkhatalakkhaº±ni. Saªkhat±na½, bhikkhave, dhamm±na½ [katam±ni t²ºi (a. ni. 3.47)] upp±do paññ±yati vayo paññ±yati, µhit±na½ aññathatta½ paññ±yat²”ti [a. ni. 3.47]. Puggalassa upp±do paññ±yati, vayo paññ±yati, µhitassa aññathatta½ paññ±yati; tena hi puggalo saªkhatoti.
215. Puggalassa na upp±do paññ±yati, na vayo paññ±yati, na µhitassa aññathatta½ paññ±yat²ti? ¾mant±. Puggalo asaªkhatoti? Na heva½ vattabbe…pe… vutta½ bhagavat±– “t²ºim±ni, bhikkhave, asaªkhatassa asaªkhatalakkhaº±ni. Asaªkhat±na½, bhikkhave, dhamm±na½ na upp±do paññ±yati, na vayo paññ±yati, na µhit±na½ aññathatta½ paññ±yat²”ti [a. ni. 3.48]. Puggalassa na upp±do paññ±yati, na vayo paññ±yati, na µhitassa aññathatta½ paññ±yati; tena hi puggalo asaªkhatoti.
216. Parinibbuto puggalo atthatthamhi, natthatthamh²ti? Atthatthamh²ti. Parinibbuto puggalo sassatoti? Na heva½ vattabbe…pe… natthatthamh²ti. Parinibbuto puggalo ucchinnoti? Na heva½ vattabbe…pe….
217. Puggalo ki½ niss±ya tiµµhat²ti? Bhava½ niss±ya tiµµhat²ti. Bhavo anicco saªkhato paµiccasamuppanno khayadhammo vayadhammo vir±gadhammo nirodhadhammo vipariº±madhammoti? ¾mant±. Puggalopi anicco saªkhato paµiccasamuppanno khayadhammo vayadhammo vir±gadhammo nirodhadhammo vipariº±madhammoti? Na heva½ vattabbe…pe….
218. Na vattabba½– “puggalo upalabbhati saccikaµµhaparamatthen±”ti? ¾mant±. Nanu atthi koci sukha½ vedana½ vediyam±no “sukha½ vedana½ vediy±m²”ti paj±n±t²ti? ¾mant± Hañci atthi koci sukha½ vedana½ vediyam±no “sukha½ vedana½ vediy±m²”ti paj±n±ti, tena vata re vattabbe– “puggalo upalabbhati saccikaµµhaparamatthen±”ti.
219. Na vattabba½– “puggalo upalabbhati saccikaµµhaparamatthen±”ti? ¾mant±. Nanu atthi koci dukkha½ vedana½ vediyam±no…pe… adukkhamasukha½ vedana½ vediyam±no “adukkhamasukha½ vedana½ vediy±m²”ti paj±n±t²ti? ¾mant±. Hañci atthi koci adukkhamasukha½ vedana½ vediyam±no “adukkhamasukha½ vedana½ vediy±m²”ti paj±n±ti, tena vata re vattabbe– “puggalo upalabbhati saccikaµµhaparamatthen±”ti.
220. Atthi koci sukha½ vedana½ vediyam±no “sukha½ vedana½ vediy±m²”ti paj±n±t²ti katv± tena ca k±raºena puggalo upalabbhati saccikaµµhaparamatthen±ti? ¾mant±. Yo sukha½ vedana½ vediyam±no “sukha½ vedana½ vediy±m²”ti paj±n±ti, sveva puggalo; yo sukha½ vedana½ vediyam±no “sukha½ vedana½ vediy±m²”ti na paj±n±ti, na so puggaloti? Na heva½ vattabbe…pe….
Yo dukkha½ vedana½ vediyam±no…pe… yo adukkhamasukha½ vedana½ vediyam±no “adukkhamasukha½ vedana½ vediy±m²”ti paj±n±ti, sveva puggalo; yo adukkhamasukha½ vedana½ vediyam±no “adukkhamasukha½ vedana½ vediy±m²”ti na paj±n±ti, na so puggaloti? Na heva½ vattabbe…pe….
221. Atthi koci sukha½ vedana½ vediyam±no “sukha½ vedana½ vediy±m²”ti paj±n±t²ti katv± tena ca k±raºena puggalo upalabbhati saccikaµµhaparamatthen±ti? ¾mant±. Aññ± sukh± vedan±, añño sukha½ vedana½ vediyam±no “sukha½ vedana½ vediy±m²”ti paj±n±t²ti? Na heva½ vattabbe…pe… aññ± dukkh± vedan±…pe… aññ± adukkhamasukh± vedan±, añño adukkhamasukha½ vedana½ vediyam±no “adukkhamasukha½ vedana½ vediy±m²”ti paj±n±t²ti? Na heva½ vattabbe …pe….
222. Na vattabba½– “puggalo upalabbhati saccikaµµhaparamatthen±”ti? ¾mant±. Nanu atthi koci k±ye k±y±nupass² viharat²ti? ¾mant±. Hañci atthi koci k±ye k±y±nupass² viharati, tena vata re vattabbe– “puggalo upalabbhati saccikaµµhaparamatthen±”ti.
223. Na vattabba½– “puggalo upalabbhati saccikaµµhaparamatthen±”ti? ¾mant±. Nanu atthi koci vedan±su…pe… citte… dhammesu dhamm±nupass² viharat²ti ¾mant±. Hañci atthi koci dhammesu dhamm±nupass² viharati, tena vata re vattabbe– “puggalo upalabbhati saccikaµµhaparamatthen±”ti.
224. Atthi koci k±ye k±y±nupass² viharat²ti katv± tena ca k±raºena puggalo upalabbhati saccikaµµhaparamatthen±ti? ¾mant±. Yo k±ye k±y±nupass² viharati, sveva puggalo; yo na k±ye k±y±nupass² viharati, na so puggaloti? Na heva½ vattabbe…pe….
Yo vedan±su…pe… citte… dhammesu dhamm±nupass² viharati, sveva puggalo; yo na dhammesu dhamm±nupass² viharati, na so puggaloti? Na heva½ vattabbe…pe….
225. Atthi koci k±ye k±y±nupass² viharat²ti katv± tena ca k±raºena puggalo upalabbhati saccikaµµhaparamatthen±ti? ¾mant±. Añño k±yo, añño k±ye k±y±nupass² viharat²ti? Na heva½ vattabbe…pe… aññ± vedan±… añña½ citta½… aññe dhamm±, añño dhammesu dhamm±nupass² viharat²ti? Na heva½ vattabbe…pe….
226. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikaµµhaparamatthen±ti? ¾mant±. Nanu vutta½ bhagavat±–
“Suññato loka½ avekkhassu, moghar±ja sad± sato;
att±nudiµµhi½ ³hacca [ohacca (sy±.), uhacca (ka.)], eva½ maccutaro siy±;
eva½ loka½ avekkhanta½, maccur±j± na passat²”ti [su. ni. 1125; c³¼ani. 88 moghar±jam±ºavapucch±niddesa].
Attheva suttantoti? ¾mant±. Tena hi na vattabba½– “puggalo upalabbhati saccikaµµhaparamatthen±”ti.
227. Puggalo avekkhat²ti? ¾mant±. Saha r³pena avekkhati, vin± r³pena avekkhat²ti? Saha r³pena avekkhat²ti. Ta½ j²va½ ta½ sar²ranti? Na heva½ vattabbe…pe… vin± r³pena avekkhat²ti, añña½ j²va½ añña½ sar²ranti? Na heva½ vattabbe…pe….
228. Puggalo avekkhat²ti? ¾mant±. Abbhantaragato avekkhati, bahiddh± nikkhamitv± avekkhat²ti? Abbhantaragato avekkhat²ti. Ta½ j²va½ ta½ sar²ranti? Na heva½ vattabbe…pe… bahiddh± nikkhamitv± avekkhat²ti, añña½ j²va½ añña½ sar²ranti? Na heva½ vattabbe…pe….
229. Na vattabba½– “puggalo upalabbhati saccikaµµhaparamatthen±”ti? ¾mant±. Nanu bhagav± saccav±d² k±lav±d² bh³tav±d² tathav±d² avitathav±d² anaññathav±d²ti? ¾mant±. Vutta½ bhagavat±– “atthi puggalo attahit±ya paµipanno”ti. Attheva suttantoti? ¾mant±. Tena hi puggalo upalabbhati saccikaµµhaparamatthen±ti.
230. Na vattabba½– “puggalo upalabbhati saccikaµµhaparamatthen±”ti? ¾mant±. Nanu bhagav± saccav±d² k±lav±d² bh³tav±d² tathav±d² avitathav±d² anaññathav±d²ti? ¾mant±. Vutta½ bhagavat±– “ekapuggalo, bhikkhave, loke uppajjam±no uppajjati bahujanahit±ya bahujanasukh±ya lok±nukamp±ya atth±ya hit±ya sukh±ya devamanuss±nan”ti [a. ni. 1.162-169]. Attheva suttantoti? ¾mant±. Tena hi puggalo upalabbhati saccikaµµhaparamatthen±ti.
231. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikaµµhaparamatthen±ti? ¾mant±. Nanu bhagav± saccav±d² k±lav±d² bh³tav±d² tathav±d² avitathav±d² anaññathav±d²ti? ¾mant±. Vutta½ bhagavat±– “sabbe dhamm± anatt±”ti [ma. ni. 1.356; dha. pa. 279 dhammapade]. Attheva suttantoti? ¾mant±. Tena hi na vattabba½– “puggalo upalabbhati saccikaµµhaparamatthen±”ti.
232. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikaµµhaparamatthen±ti? ¾mant±. Nanu bhagav± saccav±d² k±lav±d² bh³tav±d² tathav±d² avitathav±d² anaññathav±d²ti? ¾mant±. Vutta½ bhagavat±– “dukkhameva uppajjam±na½ uppajjati, dukkhameva [dukkha½ (sa½. ni. 2.15)] nirujjham±na½ nirujjhat²ti na kaªkhati na vicikicchati, aparappaccayaññ±ºamevassa ettha hoti. Ett±vat± kho, kacc±na, samm±diµµhi hot²”ti [sa½. ni. 2.15]. Attheva suttantoti? ¾mant±. Tena hi na vattabba½ “puggalo upalabbhati saccikaµµhaparamatthen±”ti.
233. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikaµµhaparamatthen±ti? ¾mant±. Nanu vajir± bhikkhun² m±ra½ p±pimanta½ etadavoca–
“Kinnu sattoti paccesi, m±ra diµµhigata½ nu te;
suddhasaªkh±rapuñjoya½, nayidha sattupalabbhati.
“Yath± hi [yath±pi (bah³su)] aªgasambh±r±, hoti saddo ratho iti;
eva½ khandhesu santesu, hoti sattoti sammuti [sammati (sy±. ka½.)].
“Dukkhameva hi sambhoti, dukkha½ tiµµhati veti ca;
n±ññatra dukkh± sambhoti, n±ñña½ dukkh± nirujjhat²”ti [sa½. ni. 1.171].
Attheva suttantoti? ¾mant±. Tena hi na vattabba½– “puggalo upalabbhati saccikaµµhaparamatthen±”ti.
234. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikaµµhaparamatthen±ti? ¾mant±. Nanu ±yasm± ±nando bhagavanta½ etadavoca– “‘suñño loko suñño loko’ti, bhante, vuccati. Kitt±vat± nu kho, bhante, ‘suñño loko’ti vuccat²”ti? “Yasm± kho, ±nanda, suñña½ attena v± attaniyena v±, tasm± ‘suñño loko’ti vuccati. Kiñc±nanda, suñña½ attena v± attaniyena v±? Cakkhu½ kho, ±nanda, suñña½ attena v± attaniyena v±, r³p± suññ±…pe… cakkhuviññ±ºa½ suñña½… cakkhusamphasso suñño… yampida½ cakkhusamphassapaccay± uppajjati vedayita½ sukha½ v± dukkha½ v± adukkhamasukha½ v±, tampi suñña½ attena v± attaniyena v±, sota½ suñña½…pe… sadd± suññ±… gh±na½ suñña½… gandh± suññ±… jivh± suññ±… ras± suññ±… k±yo suñño… phoµµhabb± suññ±… mano suñño… dhamm± suññ±… manoviññ±ºa½ suñña½… manosamphasso suñño… yampida½ manosamphassapaccay± uppajjati vedayita½ sukha½ v± dukkha½ v± adukkhamasukha½ v±, tampi suñña½ attena v± attaniyena v±. Yasm± kho, ±nanda, suñña½ attena v± attaniyena v±, tasm± ‘suñño loko’ti vuccat²”ti [sa½. ni. 4.85]. Attheva suttantoti? ¾mant±. Tena hi na vattabba½– “puggalo upalabbhati saccikaµµhaparamatthen±”ti.
235. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikaµµhaparamatthen±ti? ¾mant±. Nanu bhagav± saccav±d² k±lav±d² bh³tav±d² tathav±d² avitathav±d² anaññathav±d²ti? ¾mant±. Vutta½ bhagavat±– “attani v±, bhikkhave, sati ‘attaniya½ me’ti ass±”ti? “Eva½, bhante”. “Attaniye v±, bhikkhave, sati ‘att± me’ti ass±”ti? “Eva½, bhante”. “Attani ca, bhikkhave, attaniye ca saccato thetato anupalabbhiyam±ne [anupalabbham±ne (ma. ni. 1.244)] yampida½ [yamida½ (sy±.) yampita½ (ma. ni. 1.244)] diµµhiµµh±na½ so loko so att± so pecca bhaviss±mi nicco dhuvo sassato avipariº±madhammo, sassatisama½ tatheva µhass±m²ti– ‘nanv±ya½, bhikkhave, kevalo parip³ro b±ladhammo”’ti? “Kiñhi no siy±, bhante, kevalo hi, bhante, parip³ro b±ladhammo”ti [ma. ni. 1.244]. Attheva suttantoti? ¾mant±. Tena hi na vattabba½– “puggalo upalabbhati saccikaµµhaparamatthen±”ti.
236. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikaµµhaparamatthen±ti? ¾mant±. Nanu bhagav± saccav±d² k±lav±d² bh³tav±d² tathav±d² avitathav±d² anaññathav±d²ti? ¾mant±. Vutta½ bhagavat±– “tayo me, seniya, satth±ro santo sa½vijjam±n± lokasmi½. Katame tayo? Idha, seniya, ekacco satth± diµµheva dhamme att±na½ saccato thetato paññ±peti, abhisampar±yañca att±na½ saccato thetato paññ±peti.
“Idha pana, seniya, ekacco satth± diµµheva hi kho dhamme att±na½ saccato thetato paññ±peti, no ca kho abhisampar±ya½ att±na½ saccato thetato paññ±peti.
“Idha pana, seniya, ekacco satth± diµµhe ceva dhamme att±na½ saccato thetato na paññ±peti, abhisampar±yañca att±na½ saccato thetato na paññ±peti.
“Tatra, seniya, yv±ya½ satth± diµµhe ceva dhamme att±na½ saccato thetato paññ±peti, abhisampar±yañca att±na½ saccato thetato paññ±peti– aya½ vuccati, seniya, satth± sassatav±do.
“Tatra seniya, yv±ya½ satth± diµµheva hi kho dhamme att±na½ saccato thetato paññ±peti, no ca kho abhisampar±ya½ att±na½ saccato thetato paññ±peti– aya½ vuccati, seniya, satth± ucchedav±do.
“Tatra, seniya, yv±ya½ satth± diµµhe ceva dhamme att±na½ saccato thetato na paññ±peti, abhisampar±yañca att±na½ saccato thetato na paññ±peti– aya½ vuccati, seniya, satth± samm±sambuddho. Ime kho, seniya, tayo satth±ro santo sa½vijjam±n± lokasmin”ti [pu. pa. 131 puggalapaññattiya½, atthato eka½]. Attheva suttantoti? ¾mant±. Tena hi na vattabba½– “puggalo upalabbhati saccikaµµhaparamatthen±”ti.
237. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikaµµhaparamatthen±ti? ¾mant±. Nanu bhagav± saccav±d² k±lav±d² bh³tav±d² tathav±d² avitathav±d² anaññathav±d²ti? ¾mant±. Vutta½ bhagavat±– “sappikumbho”ti? ¾mant± Atthi koci sappissa kumbha½ karot²ti? Na heva½ vattabbe…pe… tena hi na vattabba½– “puggalo upalabbhati saccikaµµhaparamatthen±”ti.
238. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikaµµhaparamatthen±ti? ¾mant±. Nanu bhagav± saccav±d² k±lav±d² bh³tav±d² tathav±d² avitathav±d² anaññathav±d²ti? ¾mant±. Vutta½ bhagavat±– “telakumbho… madhukumbho… ph±ºitakumbho… kh²rakumbho… udakakumbho… p±n²yath±laka½… p±n²yakosaka½… p±n²yasar±vaka½… niccabhatta½… dhuvay±g³”ti? ¾mant±. Atthi k±ci y±gu nicc± dhuv± sassat± avipariº±madhamm±ti? Na heva½ vattabbe.…Pe…. Tena hi na vattabba½– “puggalo upalabbhati saccikaµµhaparamatthen±”ti. (Sa½khitta½)
Aµµhakaniggahapeyy±l±, sandh±vaniy± up±d±ya;
cittena pañcama½ kaly±ºa½, iddhisutt±haraºena aµµhama½.

Saccikaµµhasabh±g±nuyogo.

Puggalakath± niµµhit±.